Free For All: ShapeWriter for Android
Several years ago, when I bought my first generation iPod Touch, I found what could have been the greatest app in the iTunes App store, ShapeWriter. Simply put, this was the best solution I had ever found for the onscreen soft input panel. The reason I could not recommend it back then was the fact that Apple would not allow it to be used as a universal input method. In other words, it could only be used on ShapeWriter’s notes app. It all seemed like a waste of a great idea to me.
Fast forward to this past week when I started using the Android platform. Rummaging through the App Market, I suddenly remembered that the developers of ShapeWriter had not limited themselves to a single platform. Although at the time, I was disappointed not to find a Windows Mobile version (they have since developed one), they did make sure to tell me that they were developing an Android version. A quick search of the App Marketplace revealed what I had hoped to find…ShapeWriter for Android. And it was still free.
So, what is so great about ShapeWriter? Well, before we can answer that question, we need to start with why there was a need for something like this at all. Basically, there are two methods for inputting data in a mobile device: a hard keyboard and a soft input panel on the screen. Soft input panels come in all shapes and sizes, and we have tested just about all of them here at JAMM: handwriting recognition, speech to text, on-screen keyboards, fancy shorthand keyboards. Frankly, I have found them all to be terrible alternatives to a keyboard. The buttons are often cramped or unintuitive, speech or handwriting recognition never seems to work well for me (though I will admit that I have not tested out the new Dragon software which is now available for iPhone), and they are simply an exercise in tedium trying to enter more than a few words of text.
Shapewriter changed all of that for me. When activated, Shapewriter will replace the default device onscreen keyboard, and can be used with any program in which you enter text (for purposes of this review, I tested it with the default email client). At first glance, it looks a lot like just an alternative to the default keyboard. Once you start using it though, you will find so much more. Sure, you can use it like a keyboard, hunting and pecking your way around the keys, but that is really missing the point.
The real beauty of ShapeWriter is the ability to simply draw a line connecting the letters in your word. Using a powerful algorithm, which I will not pretend to understand, it translates this line into a word. What impressed me most was the level of accuracy I was able to achieve from this one. Sure, sometimes it makes a mistake and suggests the wrong word, but it always offers alternatives, one of which is generally the correct word.
If you do come up with a word that ShapeWriter does not know (which is common with proper nouns), you will be given the immediate option to add it to ShapeWriter’s dictionary. This is one of those apps which works better the more you use it. The more it learns how you draw your lines, and which words you use through its dictionary, the better it will become at predicting the words you are trying to type.
On the bottom, there is a handy emoticon button which allows you to automatically add a variety of common emoticons to your text.
The most important button, however, is the ShapeWriter action button next to it. This button enables you to take actions using a command stroke. These can include things like cut, copy, and paste, select text, and plenty more. A complete list of the command strokes can be found by pushing the action button.
To take any of these actions just start with the action button and then draw your line, connecting the letters of the command (so, action-C-U-T would send the Cut command. If you need a little extra practice with all of this, then go ahead and use the GAME command to start an included practice game.
Is it perfect? No. It still misses the occasional word for me. And I did have a few problems with the keyboard layout, such as the enter key which is awkwardly placed and too small, and some special characters were not exactly easy to locate, but those are pretty minor complaints. Overall, this is the best and fastest method of text entry I have ever used on a mobile device. I was thrilled to find it in the App Market on my HTC Hero, and even more excited to find it did not come with the senseless restrictions which made it virtually useless on the iPhone/iPod Touch. This is the first absolutely must-have app I have found in the Android App Market!
ShapeWriter was developed by www.shapewriter.com, and is available as a free download from the App Marketplace.
Related posts:
Search JAMM »
Our Sponsors
Most Popular »
- JAMM Giveaway: Get Your Favorite SplashData App For Free!
- QOTD: How Large is Too Large for a Program & Is There a Light in Size Alternative to GoodSync?
- QOTD: What Is The Best Phone on the Market?
- WiFiFoFum – Banned from the App Store, Now Out in Cydia
- SplashData Giveaway: And The Winners Are...
- Google Reader
- How Windows 7 Helped Me Enjoy a Car Ride Home
- QOTD: Which is More Important: Operating System, Applications or Operator?
- Micro SD Cards Will Be Making Contactless Payments In 2010
- Sprint’s Fumble of the NFL Mobile App Leads to A Pick Six From Verizon
- Why I Preordered the iPad Today
-
Weekend Fun: The Future Is The Past
-
PiZero Creates Another Mobile Masterpiece
-
Deal of the Day: Ringtone Shuffler for Windows Mobile
-
iPhone Apps Not Just Making Developers and Apple Richer, $ome Reviewers Want In On It Too!
-
Android 2.1 Likely Coming to Sprint, Maybe in April…or Something Like That
-
NDrive Offers A CTIA Friendly iPhone Demo Of Its Turn-by-turn Navigation System
-
BerryBuzz – BlackBerry Deal of the Day
-
Deal of the Day: SBSH PhoneWeaver 2 for Windows Mobile
-
Opera Mobile 10 And Opera Mini 5 Out Of Beta
-
Electric Pocket Brings BugMe! to iPhone
-
HTC Responds to Apple’s Patent Suit: We’re Not Going to Bow
- Me too!
This really is a useful welcome feature :)...
- Ricardo,
Thank you for following us...
- I CAN'T believe, wow, YES!
Thank you!...
- It's been a while, I've been waiting for Refresh pop!...
- Litigation and patent litigation in particular, as I have said elsewhere is the ...
- Although that will work, it still prevents you from ever being truly untethered....
- Brian: "Me, I plug in at 4 am when I get up to do consulting work"
Me: "Doh!!...
- uzziah0,
thank you for participating to the giveaway!!
I think we will have ...
- 1793 (1)
- Accessories (456)
- Android (114)
- Blackberry (149)
- Books, Music, and Media (1)
- Carrier News (129)
- Contests (160)
- Deals and Giveaways (514)
- Featured (244)
- Free For All (73)
- General (858)
- GPS devices (12)
- iPhone/iPod Touch (468)
- JAMM (159)
- JAMM Store (46)
- Laptops and Netbooks (94)
- Laptops, MIDS, and other Portable Devices (4)
- MIDS and UMPC (13)
- Other Devices (187)
- Palm/WebOS (272)
- Phones and Mobile Devices (21)
- Reviews (663)
- Symbian/Nokia (116)
- Tips and Tricks (87)
- Views (504)
- Windows Phone (1396)

6 Comments
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.David Gray
Jan 25, 2010
Since I’ve learned to trust your opinions and reviews, it would be interesting to have you do a shoot-out with this against SWYPE. Also, it appears that so far, Shapewriter only is available for WM6 and not 6.1 or 6.5. I know you were talking Android here, but until I get struck by lightning, I don’t think I’ll ever care about android. Excellent review, though, as always.
Melvyn
Jan 25, 2010
I’m using Swype on Windows Mobile which is the same idea but with a different implementation. It is far and away the best input solution I’ve used since moving to devices without a hardware keyboard.
I also think the layout is better than ShapeWriter’s. I’ve uploaded a screenshot of Swype in action here:
http://img3.imageshack.us/img3/5083/swypeinaction.jpg
I have no connection to the company and in fact my use of the tool is “unofficial” since it’s only supported and supplied on the Omnia II. Nevertheless, I’m a huge fan of their application and can’t wait for them to make it commercially available so that I can express my appreciation by buying a license!
dgoldring
Jan 25, 2010
Thanks guys. I have heard of Swype, but never used it. I looked it up, but it seems to be available for only a limited number of devices right now. If it makes its way to a device I use then I will check it out for sure.
Chris
Feb 9, 2010
@david grey -> you really should care about android if you care about high tech smart phones at all. it’s what is run on the flagship phone of both Verizon and I dare say the nexus one on t-mobile and it’s growth is much faster than winmo i’m pretty sure.
=================================================================
As for swype, well there is a leaked copy for android and I’ve used both. For accuracy of word prediction and tolerance to sloppy lines the leaked beta(?) copy is surprisingly accurate, more so than shapewriter, but that’s about all i give to swype right now until I can actually test a full non beta copy.
Shapewriter on the other hand is pretty good at picking up words. seems to learn easier, but I notice it has a tendency to pick words wrong very often, but it has the right word in the prediction list, which I find greatly annoying. for instance i slide in the word “for” and it always gives me four with for in the prediction list. things like that need to be worked on as constantly having to go to the prediction box for common words that it should pick up is time consuming. But I find I absolutely love shapewriters commands. being able to slide command a then l to select all text and delete or cut and paste is so nice with shapewriter.
I just hope they can work on the accuracy tolerance a bit more. I don’t really understand why a beta leak of swype can pick up on words so much easier then shapewriter. you don’t do your lines perfectly and it tends to read it wrong.
Meron
Feb 25, 2010
Pretty cool! but there is another keyboard that uses the same method to input text.
it’s called SlideIT and it’s on the Market.
http://mobiletextinput.com/Product/SlideIT/Android/download.php
dgoldring
Feb 25, 2010
Yes, I have seen SlideIt. It seems like a solid app. I found the plain skin to be a bit of an eyesore, but it worked well enough. The word recognition, I thought, was not as good as Shapewriter. Also, the $5.99 price tag is much more than Shapewriter (which is free) though there is a free demo of SlideIt. There is another app which is only available in limited devices, called Swype. I am waiting for that to come to my HTC Hero so I can give it a try.
Leave a Reply