Review: Ion Audio Slides2PC Scanner. What To Do With All Of Those Old Slides.


IMG_3314

Some of our less young readers probably remember a time, not so long ago, when cameras were not digital.  These stone aged behemoths of the last century captured your memories on celluloid film, most likely of the 35 mm variety.  Of course, the problem with 35 mm film was that the prints did not maintain their color well.  Older prints were often yellowed, faded, and cracked.  The better way to archive your memories was with slides.  These created much smaller prints, which could be projected onto a screen when held in front a light.  Perfect for boring all of your friends with vacation pictures. 

The problem today, though, is that as this technology was overcome by digital cameras, the tools required to display slides became more difficult to obtain.  Just try finding a good 35 mm slide projector today.  So, if you want to be able to view all of those old memories, rather than just preserving and archiving them in a shoebox, you will need to get them onto your computer.  For that, Ion Audio offers their Slides2PC slide and negative scanner.   Hit the jump for a look.

IMG_3317

OK, so let me just acknowledge that this is a bit off our normally beaten path here at JAMM.  This is not exactly a mobile device. But the truth is that I wanted to review it, because I think this is the kind of accessory which could help a lot of our readers.  Even if you have never used a non-digital camera, you had better believe that your parents are well versed in the ways of film cameras and slides.  So, there are probably some slides in your family history.

IMG_3572Crack open the box, and you will find everything you need to start digitizing your slides in minutes.  First is the scanner itself.  The nice thing about this one is the size.  For those of you who are familiar with slides, this is about the size of a lightbox viewer.  Only instead of shining a light to display the image, it shines a light to digitize the image.  In addition, there is also a tray frame to hold your slides in place, and a second one for your negatives.  It also includes all of the documentation and software you will need.

Once you have the box unpacked, you will need to setup the scanner.  This could not be any easier.  Just unpack the included CD-ROM and slip it into the drive.  This will install all of the necessary drivers for the scanner, as well as the Arcsoft PhotoImpressions package.   Now, just grab that USB plug dangling off the back and plug it into your computer.  That’s it.  You are all setup and ready to scan those slides.

IMG_3565

OK. The first thing you are going to want to do is put your slides into the scanning frame.  I was frustrated that the frame can only handle three slides at a time.  This means an awful lot of swapping in and out.  Frankly, I suspect most people using a slide scanner are going to be interested in digitizing their entire slide library, which can mean thousands of slides.  Loading them three at a time can be a bit tedious.  It would be nice if the scanner offered a way to load an entire slide carousel at once.  I would happily trade portability (I don’t really travel with slides these days) for usability like that.Capture2

Now, this is where that Arcsoft software comes into play.  Go ahead and open it up.  It is really quite easy to use, and select obtain from scanner.  Just choose the appropriate settings and you are ready to go.  You’ll see a new screen which displays the images from your scanner. 

IMG_3567

Just insert the frame with the slides into the slot.  Like I said, you will see what the scanner sees as it will be displayed on the screen.  Once the first slide is aligned, hit the capture button to scan the image.  Then, keep sliding the frame until the second slide is displayed and the third.  I was really disappointed by how manual this scanner was.  I had hoped (and maybe not reasonably, I don’t know) for more automation.  It would have been nice if the frame could have been fed into the scanner and the three slides would be automatically captured.  This is not a big problem if you are scanning a few slides at a time.  But I have thousands of slides in a multitude of carousels, all of which I would like to digitize and store.  The thought of scanning each slide manually one at a time is really not particularly appealing.

1-31-2009_001 IMG_3562

The real question with the Slides2PC, though, is how the pictures come out on your computer.  So, let’s take a look.  Here is a slide from my childhood which I scanned using the Slides2PC (left).  It is hard to show on the computer, but  I am doing my best to show you the original slides here (right).   The image resembles the original slides, but the colors all look washed out and overexposed.  I may have missed a setting in there, but really, I was not very happy with the quality of the final images.  If the point of scanning your slides is to preserve and archive the images, this is probably not going to cut it.

What I Liked:

  • Small and portable
  • Easy to setup and use
  • Nice software package

 

What Needs Improvement:

  • Only three slides fit in a frame
  • No automation, each slide must be scanned individually and manually
  • Washed out colors

 

Where To Buy: Ion Audio

Price: $99.99

More in Reviews | 11 Comments

11 Comments

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.


pedah
Feb 7, 2009

What do you mean, "our less young readers" ?


Dsgoldring
Feb 9, 2009

If you can remember a time when we used film in cameras and displayed vacation pics on a large screen using a slide and slide projector, then you might be "less young" than those who never knew such oddities of history. :)


JAD
Mar 16, 2009

I have used this and found that on a perfectly exposed slide, the automatic colour works ok. The problem lies with exposure of small light areas such as faces against dark backgrounds, this causes the faces of people (if light skinned) to be washed out. I have found a workaround by putting individual (awkward) slides in the front carrier slot only. Before inserting into scanner I waited until the unit self calibrated by turning to neutral grey, then I push the slide into scanner. I then get ready to push the button at the right time before the auto exposure system messes up. This brings back the detail in faces and then all that is needed is some tweaking in a photo editor. All in all this unit would be better if there was a manual control override for the exposure/colour balance system. ION please address.


Marcel theriault
Mar 30, 2009

I bought one 6 months ago and have spent days (I’m a retired photographer- teaching photography) trying to get some support. Maybe the Ion company made a big mistake putting those gadget on the market. I was able to find the manufacturer in China without getting an answer. Amazon tried to help me without success. I have a piece of plastic between the filter in front of the CCD and I want to take it apart at my own risk and try to fix it. I bought it at 79.00$ US and paid over 180.00$ by the time it reached me in CANADA, Exchange, UPS, Customs, etc.
My advise Stay away for the product, poor quality and bad service.
Buy a cheap 2 MP camera and photograph you slides in a window and you’ll get a better result.


dgoldring
Mar 31, 2009

I agree, Marcel. I am by no means a professional photographer, but I know my way around a camera well enough, and I am pretty familiar with digital photography. I found this slide scanner to be much more difficult than it should have been, and even when it worked, the quality was way below my expectations.

Doug


Erwin
Jul 10, 2009

to JAD, the over exposure is really a problem, I also tried everything to get the original brightness and colors of the dia ……. without any success so far……


Keith
Dec 27, 2009

I just bought the ION film/slide 2 SD and am wondering why something touted as a 5 megapixel scanner only manages to produce 900 KB files?

Am I missing something here or was I taken for a ride?


merrick callegari
Jul 19, 2010

i just got mine in the mail. ion makes really user unfriendly and less than great products. i will never purchase an ion product again.


Thekla
Sep 2, 2010

I finally started with my slides to digitalize them with ION. Me too I’m very disapointed in the product. My slides come out as if they are very old and washed out.


Motorsheep
Dec 16, 2010

After purchasing the ION and trying for several days to get any acceptable output from it I finally caved in, borrowed a slide projector, and shot the projected slides with a digital camera. This produced better results than this scanner. Yes, if you have a PERFECT slide it does a passable job, but even then it tends to color things blue and pixellates shadowed areas. On almost everything else the result is heart-breakingly bad and in many cases unrecognizable from the original image. If you plan on archiving slides then invest in a higher-end machine like a Nikon or even a used Kodak scanner… even some less expensive flatbed scanners with slide attachments do far far better than this toy.


John
Sep 27, 2011

I’ll try a neutral density filter if I can find one and maybe it’ll add color to the washouts.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.